Contested history

Where the sources disagree

Each topic gathers the competing accounts of one question — from within Johnson's text and beyond — ranked by evidence, never flattened into false balance. The best-evidenced account reads as primary; the others stay one tap away, each with its provenance and the reason for its rank.

Every account here is carefully reviewed and cited before it appears. Know of a tradition or source we’ve missed? We’d love to hear from you — see About to get in touch.